Re-treated root canal or dental implant?

[grace]

About two years ago I had a root canal procedure done on one of my second premolar teeth. The gums around the tooth is now red and infected, and I have been told that there is bone loss around the tooth. My first dentist told me that I would have to go see a periodontist for an extraction/implant to replace the tooth altogether. Then I went for a second opinion and the second dentist said that since I am young, (30) and the previous root canal was not done on the entire root of my tooth, that he would re-do the procedure correctly.

I then began to do some research on my own and found an extensive study that was done which showed how root canals lead to degenerative diseases later in life. Now I am completely confused and not sure what choice is the best one. Do I just do the implant and deal with not having a tooth for 7 months, or do I go through with the second root canal and hope for the best for my future health??

 

[JJ_8613]

Hi.

I've never had a root canal re-treatment before, but I'm also looking into the possibility of needing one currently.

My understanding is that the success rate for a re-treatment is not always great. I'd have an endodontist check the tooth. They are specialized in dealing with this and may be better equipped to handle it than a regular dentist. If I need a re-treatment I'm getting it done by a specialist.

From what I've heard it's always better to try to save the tooth if you can. Implants are expensive, especially if it's not absolutely necessary.

It's up to you, but typically I think a re-treatment is recommended, unless the tooth isn't strong enough for the treatment.

Do you have a crown on this tooth? Is the tooth causing you any pain?

Good luck and please keep us updated.

JJ